Clay Holmes’ potential departure from the Yankees, especially to join their arch-rival Red Sox, would indeed be a big development. After being removed as New York’s closer following a season-high 13 blown saves, Holmes rebounded well in a non-closer role, which helped rebuild his market value. MLBTradeRumors has predicted that he’ll sign a three-year, $30 million deal with Boston, a substantial raise from his $6.05 million salary with New York.
Holmes’ struggles in high-pressure save situations, culminating in the memorable September 3 grand slam against the Rangers, likely influenced the Yankees’ decision to reassign him. However, his strong peripheral stats and performance as a high-leverage reliever still make him an attractive option for teams seeking bullpen depth. Boston’s bullpen, which could use a reliable, experienced arm, might view Holmes as a potential closer or setup man, similar to the role he filled effectively for New York after being removed from the ninth inning.
If this move happens, it would not only provide Holmes a fresh start but also intensify the rivalry between the Yankees and Red Sox, with Holmes possibly having the chance to redeem himself in big matchups against his former team.
Where Would Holmes Fit in With Red Sox?
If Clay Holmes does sign with the Red Sox, he’d have a promising shot at becoming the team’s closer, especially with Kenley Jansen’s impending free agency. Jansen, who converted 27 of 31 save chances in 2024 and completed his $32 million contract, will likely draw significant interest from teams needing a seasoned closer. Should Boston be unable to retain Jansen, Holmes would become a natural candidate for the ninth inning.
Holmes’ experience with the Yankees, especially his improved performance as a setup man after losing the closer role, could make him a valuable asset in a high-leverage role. His 3.14 ERA over 67 appearances in the regular season and 2.25 ERA across 12 playoff innings reflect his ability to perform under pressure, particularly when not limited to the closer role.
If the Red Sox choose to use Holmes as a setup man instead, it would also play to his strengths and bring added stability to Boston’s bullpen, especially if they reconfigure the closer role with another acquisition.
Yankees Still Showed Confidence in Holmes
Even after removing Clay Holmes from the closer role, the Yankees showed clear trust in his abilities throughout the playoffs. Manager Aaron Boone continued to express confidence in Holmes, emphasizing that while Holmes had a rough patch with blown saves, his command and overall stuff remained strong. Boone’s support reflects the organization’s belief that Holmes could still contribute effectively, even outside the closer role.
Holmes ultimately proved valuable in high-leverage situations during the postseason, showcasing his ability to adapt and perform under pressure. His late-season success could be a key factor in his appeal as a free agent. If he does join the Red Sox, his experience handling high-stakes moments could position him either as a closer or a trusted setup man, depending on Boston’s roster moves this offseason.
Leave a Reply